On 12 January, the European Social Network (ESN) participated at a focus group meeting organised by Eurohealthnet as part of the VulnerABLE pilot project that focusses on Evidence-Based Strategies to Improve the Health of Isolated and Vulnerable Groups.
At the focus group meeting, ESN contributed to discussions about services for people with disabilities and mental health problems. Because identifying evidence on disability and mental health policy and services is crucial, ESN addressed this in a series of events between 2014-2015. For ESN, the main reason for putting this theme on the agenda is that the availability of robust evidence can make a significant difference in improving policy and practice.
Eurohealthnet has been tasked by the European Commission to implement the VulnerABLE project. The project aims to identify and recommend effective policy strategies for improving the health of people with disabilities and poor mental health. The focus group scheduled to discuss preliminary findings from the project.
Risk factors for the health of disadvantaged groups
People with disabilities or mental health problems face an increased risk of being exposed to poverty, social exclusion, low-quality housing, and unemployment. These factors interact in different ways with the health of people in these vulnerable groups. While low-quality housing may impact directly on people’s health for example by causing asthma, unemployment may put people in a situation where a shortage of money means they cannot afford to pay for treatment.
Lack of robust data as a barrier to policy and practice development
Participants at the focus group meeting discussed the prevalence of disabilities and mental health problems. The EU’s statistics office, EUROSTAT, estimates the number of people with disability in the EU to be at 73,030,600 people. Europe-wide research reckons that around 38.2 percent of EU citizens are affected by mental health problems, which represents ca. 164,8 million people. The most prevalent mental health problems include anxiety, severe depression, and the consequences of substance abuse. However, the collection of data across different classifications of disability and mental health problems has proven to be difficult. This presents a barrier to policy and practice development, notably because allocating budgets to meet needs can be difficult in the absence of reliable data.
Need for evidence-based methods
At the meeting, participants concluded that truly tested methods were scarce for a number of reasons. In the first place, carrying out evaluations requires resources, which might not be equally available across all countries. Second, clearly identifying drivers of success in services is a challenge given the multiple layers of a person’s life and the complexity of individual needs. And third, even where successful evaluations have been carried out, barriers to transferability of the reviewed methods often exist.
A key conclusion from the meeting was that evidence will be critical for the development of better health policy and practice for vulnerable groups. Whilst policy development would require more detailed statistical data on the prevalence of disabilities and mental health problems, practice development would benefit from more evidence-based methods and a deeper understanding of ‘what works for whom’ on an individual basis.
- European Social Network (2016) vidence-based social services: Toolkit for planning & evaluating social services
- Wittchen (2011)The size and burden of mental disorders and other disorders of the brain in Europe 2010
- European Commission (2013) Mental health Systems in the European Union Member States, Status of Mental Health in Populations and Benefits to be Expected from Investments into Mental Health European profile of prevention and promotion of mental health (EuroPoPP-MH)